I was reading over somebody’s shoulder today, waiting for a Go Train that never seemed to come.
They were reading a novel that had lots of blurbs on the front cover: “Riveting” and “A compelling read” and “Best Freakin’ Book Ever” kind of thing.
So reading over this woman’s shoulder I was strike by the prose. Kind of bland. Prose like “They got in the car. The car took them outside the town.” Hemingway wrote like that, didn’t he? Straight and to the point. I’m not saying there’s anything wrong with that, but I thought it was interesting because it’s not the way I write. I like prose with a little pizzazz to it, like the kind Bill Bryson and Douglas Adams write. You know, like the kind you’re not likely to get much of in, say, a blog like this.
Anyway, the other thing I noticed was the use of adverbs. As in, “Get in the car,” he told her merrily. “Okay,” she replied happily.
I don’t really know why, but I almost never use adverbs like that. I’m prejudiced against them for some reason. Just the same, sometimes I’m worried that not using adverbs like that hurts my prose, or even my story. Because it’s so much easier just to write:
“Put that thing down,” Rainer said irritably.
Then readers know Rainer’s irritated; I don’t have to think about it, and my readers don’t have to think about it. But I almost never do it because some instinct tells me it’s better if I show that Rainer’s irritated. Such as:
Rainer furrowed his brow. “Put that thing down,” he said.
Or do it with dialog: “Put that goddamn thing down,” Rainer said.
Or string them all together:
Rainer furrowed his brow. “Put that goddamn thing down,” he told Harold, shortly before snatching the mandolin from Harold’s hands and shoving it up his ass.
Ahem.
Now, I have no doubt that the book I glimpsed was a compelling read, and that the use of adverbs didn’t hurt the story one iota. And writing that way I bet you complete novels more quickly than with the approach I take, in which I agonize over each word, each sentence, each unused adverb.
It just ain’t my style.
Myself I blame Fred Obermeyer, an online pal who has critiqued some of my writing. Fred hates adverbs, and it’s his cybervoice I hear every time I use one: “Don’t think you need that adverb, Joe,” he’d write. “It dilutes the prose,” or the like.
Damn you, Fred. But I agree with you.
Sadly, I’ve never actually met Fred in person. Someday I hope to get the chance to tell him in person:
“Thanks for the advice,” I’d tell him earnestly.
Heh heh.